Log in

No account? Create an account
22 April 2011 @ 06:41 pm
Round 3 // Challenge 11 Results  


Sadly we have to say goodbye to the following user:

kibethsbark (with +10 votes)
(Congratulations on obtaining 4th place in Round 3!)

Members' Choice:

Congratulations to the following user for submitting the favourite set for this challenge:

realproof (with -5 votes)

( + ) = Least favourite ("negative") votes
( - ) = Favourite ("positive") votes
Lower numbers indicate higher scores
If your icon number is not listed, that means you received no votes

1. +2 - -4 = -2
2. -2 = -2
3. +5 = +5
4. -2 = -2
5. +2 - -1 = +1
6. -2 = -2
7. +5 = +5
8. -3 = -3

Icon A: -2; Icon B: +1
Icon A: -2; Icon B: -2
Icon A: +5; Icon B: +5
TOTAL: +10
Icon A: -2; Icon B: -3

If you would like to see your vote comments, please leave a comment here with your icon number. Indicate whether you would like your feedback in a screened or unscreened comment, thank you.
Dorota: v - anna - lonely queenxafirah on April 22nd, 2011 08:48 am (UTC)
Comments for #2 & #6 please, unscreened is fine :) Thank you.
Amsie: Impressiveshadowserenity on April 22nd, 2011 08:51 am (UTC)
Here we go. Best of luck for the next challenge!

- Good natural colouring, and good use of lighting to bring out the foreground.
- nice clear coloring.

- Flawless b/w work here - very nice contrast, good sharpness (which I know wasn't easy with that cap).
- great contrast and focus
-realproof on April 22nd, 2011 08:56 am (UTC)
thank you.

@obaona, I really liked your Ezri-icon :)
Amsie: Cylon Evolutionshadowserenity on April 22nd, 2011 01:25 pm (UTC)
Good luck with the final challenge, btw! :)
Carlykibethsbark on April 22nd, 2011 01:11 pm (UTC)
Thanks for bringing me this far! I'm not surprised (I had more difficulty with these caps than I anticipated I would). :)

Could I have my comments please? Unscreened is fine. :)
Amsie: Of Peaceshadowserenity on April 22nd, 2011 01:28 pm (UTC)
Thanks so much for participating in this round :). It was a pleasure to have you.

- the icon seems blurry overall, and the colouring is a bit flat and slightly too cyan.
- The crop is great, but the icon seems blurry around her cheeks, and then over sharpened in the right corner.
- The coloring is very nice but the center crop and lack of textures seem to make it a bit uninteresting.
- poor image quality (she's blurry) and her nose is very over-brightened, it looks white.
- Dax is a bit blurry in the face, especially around her cheeks and eyes.

- the icon is quite dark (especially in her face) and blurry.
- It's too dark (needs more Brighten/Contrast) and a bit too blurry.
- The crop is good but the black and white looks a bit too gray (there's not really a "white" per say in it) makes the icon fade into the background.
- blurry, and she kind of gets lost, because the contrast is low - she blends into the background.
- The B&W needs more contrast and sharpening.
oba: futurama - fryobaona on April 22nd, 2011 08:53 pm (UTC)
Yay, I made it! If only barely. ;) Can I have comments for 1 and 5, please? Unscreened is fine, thank you. :)
Amsie: Run Far Awayshadowserenity on April 27th, 2011 08:35 am (UTC)
- the crop works well, as does the soft background.
- Pretty colors, great use of negative space. I love blurred background.
- The greenish texture is a little overwhelming in this icon, and makes her features appear a little fuzzy.
- I really like the green, and the texture in the background, but her face is too yellow. It makes her look sick - keeping it more pink would add more contrast with the background as well.
- The coloring is great and the use of the texture in the back works really well.
- love the background colours; they frame Dax beautifully.

- Nice job removing the background, beautiful sharpness, and I really like the focus on the gun.
- Great colouring, but the background is a little plain/jarring on this one; maybe a little texture or changing the lighting up a bit might help blend everything together and make the icon feel a little more cohesive.
- Coloring is very nice but the area around her right ear is too sharp while her left side is blurry.